Maisie Chin believes that supervision can be transformative. As Executive Director/Co-Founder of CADRE, transformation is what their organization is all about. Since 2001 CADRE has been working with parents to transform education by ending and replacing the school to prison pipeline with healthy, restorative school climates. As a result of their work with parents the past 16 years, there have been major policy changes in the LA school district which resulted in a 90% reduction in suspensions and alternative, more positive interventions for behavior.
Maisie sees her work as a supervisor primarily as a facilitator. She works to bring out people’s best. That was not the case with some of her own supervisors. In particular, she learned what NOT to do from one previous supervisor. Maisie learned how disruptive it was when a supervisor acted inconsistently and did not keep her word. Her former boss would treat her staff erratically based on her own good or bad moods. Maisie learned how important it was to follow through on commitments and to act consistently.
The mission of CADRE is what drives Maisie’s work. She understands that to make real changes in the community, people have to make real changes in their own lives. It is not enough to tell an employee to stop doing ineffective work. It is not enough to have them do routine tasks if those tasks are not done in a purposeful manner that supports the mission of the organization. Therefore, Maisie recognizes the importance of helping her staff understand how their beliefs and actions are impacting the work when she sees that happening. For instance, “If staff are resistant to feedback and that gets in the way of their work, just telling them what to do is not enough,” says Maisie. “We have to find out why they’re resistant, how it impacts the fulfillment of their role and potential, and whether that approach is really their choice.”
Direct feedback becomes a critical part of the facilitation of a supervisor. “I know I respond better to immediate feedback,” Maisie says, “and so I give immediate feedback. If the feedback is not immediate, the wrong actions might be repeated and then it becomes harder to change. I’d rather risk hurting your feelings now by teaching you the right way to do it.”
Maisie has trained and practiced as a coach and she brings her coaching approach to her supervision. She helps her staff develop personal awareness and skills for work and for life. Skills like self-reflection and understanding how their past shows up in their work and reactions. She mentors her staff to work intentionally, in alignment with the mission. Occasionally staff don’t want that kind of supervision. They just want to be told what to do or to work transactionally. In those cases, they resist the coaching or simply tell Maisie what they think she wants to hear. That doesn’t work. Those staff members eventually choose to leave.
When staff work with her, the transformation is powerful – and then they can carry on the power of transformation into their work with parents and their own goals. “It is a privilege to do social justice work, so I have high standards of being in alignment and acting with integrity. I expect my staff to honor the privilege and the community by doing that also. Everything I do is about the work and how we do our work – because it equals how we treat our community of parents, which is what will be remembered the most.”
Maisie’s work with CADRE is an example of effective supervision aligned with and in support of a powerful mission. It makes a huge difference. Supervision matters!
Congratulations! You’re a new supervisor and now you supervise former peers. Let’s look at some important tips for new supervisors to set the stage for success – for you and your new staff.
Ask questions and listen deeply to understand what is expected of you. Review your job description with your own supervisor and make sure you are clear about where your authority lies. What can you do on your own and what must be approved? Ask questions to discern the culture of supervisors from the management perspective. What is expected of you and other new supervisors in this role?
You may know your staff well, but you don’t know them as a supervisor. Ask them questions and listen intently from your new vantage point.
It is always awkward when new supervisors have to supervise someone who thought they should have gotten the job. Make a plan with your supervisor for the three of your to meet. Your supervisor can establish your authority in a clear, direct and professional manner that leave no room for second guessing the decision that make you supervisor. This is not an adversarial meeting; the focus is on clarity.
After you’ve met with each staff member individually, bring the team together. Discuss your vision for the team, how you see your role, what your style is and what you expect from your former peers. Invite their questions and concerns. Act with confidence but not bravado. The position is yours. Step into the role.
Determine how often you need to meet with each team member. This might be weekly for new or struggling staff. With other staff, it might be every other week. With strongly confident and established staff, it might be monthly. Get these meetings on the books for the next few months and prioritize them. This is a critical practice of new supervisors, and seasoned ones as well.
One of the most important tasks of supervisors is to let your staff know what is working and what is not working. Acknowledge the successes and support the positive actions. Address any problems as they come up. Give feedback in a neutral and clear manner. This is information each person needs to be successful.
You may be friends with some of your former peers. But now you have a different role and you need to understand the impact of your actions as a supervisor. At work, you must treat everyone the same. No favors for your friends. No extra information for your friends. No complaining to your friends. No chatting about your a party you went to with some staff members. At work, you are the supervisor. Period. Be friendly and supportive of everyone but do not show favorites.
Be fair. Apply rules and procedures consistently. Keep up with your meetings, both the one-on-ones and the team meetings. Hold people accountable in the same manner. If you say you’ll do something, make sure you do it. If you make a mistake, admit it.
Find someone who has been a supervisor and ask them for help and support as you transition to this new role of being a supervisor. This might be your own supervisor, a supervisor from another department or company or it might be a coach. Find someone that you can ask for help and speak the true challenges you are facing.
You are now a manager; you are one of many supervisors in the organization. You are still on your own team but you are also on this new team of management. Find out what the rules of this new team are and how they act together. When you are called to deliver news or ask for information or apply a new policy, don’t set yourself up as a simple messenger. Speak for yourself; don’t hid behind anyone by using words like “them” or “have to” or I wouldn’t.” Own the change and speak it clearly. You can still hear any concerns that might come your way but don’t set yourself up against management. You are now one of them.
When you apply these tips, you will be a star among the new supervisors!
Congratulations! You landed the promotion and now you will be a supervisor. In fact, you will be a supervisor of your former peers. BE CAREFUL! This is a tricky transition and many dangers lie ahead.
Here’s a quick summary of traps to avoid to successfully maneuver the transition.
Stay tuned for TIPS to set you and your team up for success as you move into the role of being a supervisor and prepare to lead your former peers.
It can be difficult to supervise an introvert. Introverts tend to be quiet and thoughtful and somewhat reserved. They probably won’t be the first to offer a solution to a problem, but they may offer the best solution if you wait a minute.
Here are five tips to help you supervise introverts at work:
Send out meeting agendas to those you supervise a day ahead of time if there are going to be discussion items. The introverts in the group will have time to think about the topic and will be more likely to come prepared to discuss options and ideas.
Practice this with the individuals you supervise too: “I’d like to hear some ideas from you about how we could improve our customer service. Let’s discuss this at our next 1:1 meeting.” Or, “Think about how this could have gone better. Let’s meet tomorrow at 2:00 to discuss it.”
oWhen the work day ends, very few peost work cultures now are 24/7. Make it clear that it is not only ok to take breaks and vacations but that it is expected. Model that expectation. Don’t supervise in a manner that gives lip service to down time but then send emails at 3:00 in the morning and another one at 6:00 saying “I haven’t heard back from you yet.”
Introverts often have a hard time being heard in meetings. This can be addressed by training people to facilitate the meetings. Find a way to train some (or all) people in basic facilitation skills, like how to stop cross talking and how to ask for input without putting people on the spot. The facilitation role can be rotated on a regular basis (e.g. weekly) among the meeting participants. Then everyone will be more thoughtful about how to include everyone else in the discussion.
Don’t wait to hear about problems until they are large problems. As you supervise, be clear about when and how to bring concerns up the ladder. Train the whole team in basic conflict resolution skills. This will save countless hours lost to interpersonal conflicts. It would also be great to train people about personality styles so they know that a different style doesn’t mean worse, just different.
Not all leaders are outgoing and charismatic. Recognize and talk about quiet leaders. Acknowledge the employees who offer quiet and effective solutions or ideas. Supervise and mentor the quiet leaders as well as the extroverted ones.
Introverts have a lot to contribute to the work place but it may look and sound different than the way extroverts contribute. Be a supervisor who makes room to see and hear and support everyone on your team.
Hiring is one of the most important tasks you have when you’re a manager. You invest a lot of time and money when you hire a new staff member. And if you get it wrong, it can cost even more.
So here’s five quick tips to consider when you’re facing that empty desk in your department.
Have fun with the process. Let the candidate know the kind of manager you are as well as what the job is. Pay attention to these five tips and you will be more likely to get someone competent to work at that empty desk.
As a supervisor, you want to teach your staff to succeed and do good work. Too often, however, supervisors inadvertently teach their staff not to listen to them. When supervisors teach their staff not to listen to them, it can lead to frustration for the supervisor. It can also create big problems for the organization when work is not completed the way it should be. It is surprisingly easy to teach them not to listen to you, without even trying!
1. Make your staff feel unheard.
When you don’t listen to your staff, they are much more likely to not listen to you. They will listen enough to get by but that’s it. If you truly want them to hear you, you must listen to them. Not just in the moment but consistently
2. Say the same thing over and over again.
When anyone says the same thing over and over again, it is natural to tune them out after awhile. When this happens in the same conversation, it becomes a lecture. And people stop listening.
3. Do other things when you talk.
Check your phone, look through papers on your desk, write notes to yourself. When you show your staff that there are other things as important, or more important, then them, they will get the message. They will feel disrespected and will be much more likely to do the same to you.
4. Contradict yourself.
Tell them one thing and then, soon after, contradict yourself. Tell them what the top priority for their work is and then change it soon after, without acknowledging that this is a change. Or tell one thing to one staff member and tell another staff member the opposite. This will ensure that no one really listens to you because they know that the information might change in 5 minutes or 5 days.
5. Speak out of alignment with your actions.
Tell them one thing and act in a way that shows you don’t mean it. For example, give your staff a rousing speech about teamwork and then promote the staff member who is the most competitive person around. Or say you value work-life balance, and then question why a staff member didn’t respond to the text you sent at midnight.
Any of these actions will tell your staff that you are not consistent, you are not trustworthy and it would be a waste of time to listen to you.
Evaluations are stressful for everyone, supervisors, staff members and even HR. The point of evaluations is often lost in the pressure to get something in the file by a looming deadline. While evaluations may never be anyone’s favorite process, they can document an important conversation. Remember these key five points to make the evaluation process relevant and not just an exercise in paper-generation.
Don’t use the evaluation to just capture problems or areas of improvement. Make sure you note the successes and learning that happened since the last evaluation.
This is the golden rule of evaluations. Any information that is important enough to warrant mention in the evaluation, should not be a surprise to the employee. If you haven’t addressed the concern before, then own up to your mistake. And don’t let it happen again next year.
Anything you mention must be job-related. How does this action or behavior impact the employee’s work? If you can’t connect the dots, then how is it relevant to the evaluation? No comments about how nice someone is, unless that is a required job skill. If it is important to their work, explain the connection.
Although HR requires the form, the point of the process is the conversation with the staff member. The evaluation form should document the conversation and not vice versa. Give more time and attention to the actual conversation with the employee than to the form. Make the conversation matter.
The evaluation process is designed to look at the past year and it is important to summarize and evaluate progress periodically. Use the “look-back” to give feedback and information about what worked and what didn’t work. Then spend the bulk of the time on facing the future together. What needs to be different in the coming year? What opportunities are available? How will you build on successes? What are the top priorities moving forward? Where does the staff member want to stretch and grow? What goals will you set together and support them to reach? That’s the fun part and it deserves the most attention.
When done well, the evaluation can serve as a process to ensure you and your staff members are on the same page about where things stand and what the priorities are for the new year. At its best, this evaluation conversation can leave you both energized and enthusiastic for the year to come
Gotcha is the moment when one person catches another person in a trap. Often this is an unspoken “gotcha” but it is there nevertheless. This words great in a strategy games like chess, but supervisors erode trust when they play gotcha with their staff. After a few incidents of gotcha, staff members understand that their supervisor’s intention is to catch them, not to support them.
There is little room for playing gotcha in a workplace. There are some supervisors though who love those moments and there are others who inadvertently spring those moments on their staff. Playing gotcha does not help your staff to learn or grow. Supervisors lead best with curiosity, not by playing gotcha!
Curiosity – Not Interrogation
When supervisors don’t understand an action that a staff member took, they often try to find out what they were thinking. This can lead to an inadvertent gotcha moment. Questions can be a valuable tool, but it is important that you bring genuine curiosity to the questioning; otherwise it can come across as interrogation.
“Why did you speak to your client in that manner?”
“Don’t you know the procedure for updating the website?”
“Haven’t we discussed this several times previously?”
“Did you think you had a better way to do this process than the rest of the staff?”
“Tell me what was going through your mind when you spoke to your client.”
“We have a procedure for updating the website. Has that ever been reviewed with you?”
“Tell me what you remember about our previous discussions and I’ll fill in any gaps.”
“What led you to doing this process in a different way?”
When supervisors are in interrogation mode, they assume that they know everything there is to know about the situation. These supervisors don’t really care what the staff member has to say; they just want to make a point.
When supervisors are curious, however, they genuinely want to hear what the staff member has to say. They recognize that they might learn something. And the supervisor’s intention is to help the staff member be successful.
Not only are the curious questions less aggressive in the initial exchange, they set up the staff member to have an honest exchange with their supervisor, to keep talking to them and to trust them. The interrogation tells the staff member that there is only one right answer and that the supervisor is the one who knows it. As a consequence, the staff member won’t bother to tell their supervisor what they were thinking or why they tried something new; they will just try to get the “right” answer and move on. Over time, interrogation questions erode trust and impact the work in dramatic fashion.
Good supervisors don’t practice gotcha with their staff. They lead with curiosity to build trust. Unless, of course, they’re actually playing chess.